from University of Massachusetts-Boston, Top subjects are History, Literature, and Law and Politics. Ethical dilemmas in dental assisting. The oldest child, nine year old Angie has anterior decay across all her maxillary teeth and the youngest, three year old Sophie has only black stubs for teeth. For example, practitioners are required to maintain their level of knowledge and skill through participation in appropriate continuing education programs. CPS workers usually take one to two weeks to respond on non-emergency issues, according to the website. The choices we make in response to these dilemmas serve to determine the moral character of the dental assistant. Ethical Dilemmas in Oral Health Care; Principles in Dentistry and Dental Hygiene. Ethical dilemmas are nothing more than complex situations that involve two or more choices that by selecting either of the choices would result in some sort of conflict or transgression. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Option #5 would be also be part of the treatment plan. What are the most important factors in producing ethical decisions in health care? The dental practice appears to have a relationship with the local church, what guidance do they provide for these folks and do they cover the cost of care --- a clerk at the church helps set up appointments and the church pays for basic care. 2 For example, a patient requests a 12-month recare schedule due to financial difficulties (autonomy), but the dental hygienist believes that 4-month appointments are what the patient needs to improve his oral health (beneficence). The biggest challenge of ethical dilemma is that it does not offer an obvious solution that would comply with ethical norms. However, Boards of Dentistry often cite ethics as causative in cases considered by these agencies. How common are ethical dilemmas in dentistry? ©2020 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. As you read through these vignettes, consider how you would handle similar situations. What does it mean to have "ethical wisdom" when it comes to morals and values in a health care organization? You are a new clinician in an established dental clinic in a large urban area that sees patients from many different immigrant groups. Here are 10 dental negligence cases that can help you determine if you’re a victim of dental medical negligence: Case #1: Extractions. In some cases… The child's parents are there and explain that they work several low-paying jobs to provide for their children. Is this dental neglect or dental ignorance? Are all staff members on the same page? One day, the interpreter for a new family comes to you concerned about the three children whom she is interviewing for your next screening appointments that afternoon. She talks about what she would like to cook for you and the nice people in the office. Below are some hypothetical ethical dilemmas a dentist may encounter. Already a member? The patient informs the clinician that they are a recovering addict. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Are you a teacher? Ethical Dilemmas in Dentistry 13 Dentist/Patient Issues 13 Ethical Issues in Dental Fees and Insurance 18 Dentist and Colleague/Employee Issues 19 Ethical Law 20 Ethical Theories 21 Application of Ethical Theories 21 Conclusion 23 References 24 Course Test 26 . Corporate quotas: An ethical dilemma for dental hygienists. Ethical Dilemma Examples Ethical dilemmas are situations in which there is a difficult choice to be made between two or more options, neither of which resolves the situation in a manner that is consistent with accepted ethical guidelines. The patient informs the dentist that they cannot afford to pay for the sealants. in the dental field. READ MORE | Ethical dilemma: Dental hygienists who work while sick Another way to prevent this dilemma would be a full office review of each hygiene patient in the daily huddle. No studies or evidence exists documenting the volume of problems. I'll be discussing the Return On Investment (ROI) of doing a dental residency in another post. If low morale is … An ethical Dilemma! It is a lot of work to succeed in these offices, but if you utilize textbook dentistry, it’s not that tough. Your corporate employer asks you to perform an SRP you know isn't needed. The following examples of ethical challenges in dentistry are taken from my own experience with the exception of the last example. How do patient rights affect how health care workers interact with patients? Ethical Dilemmas in Oral Health Care The two main goals involved in ethics are the ability to discern right from wrong and the commitment to act on a decision. The choices we make in response to these dilemmas serve to determine the moral character of each dental assistant. Call child care services and report the cases of dental neglect in these two children. The interpreter and the clinician have observed that dental disease is present and meets the definition of neglect – what would the likely course of action be from child protective services for these children based on history and information. To illustrate supervised neglect, two case examples show common dental care dilemmas hygienists experience — periodontal disease treated conservatively in high-risk patients, and radiographic refusal. While it is usually clear to determine when to report a flagrant incident of child abuse, borderline cases can be much more difficult to evaluate, creating a moral and ethical dilemma. For example, if you are asked about a patient with dental decay who refuses to use fluoride toothpaste you could discuss what your understanding is of both dental decay and the use of fluoride. Call child care services for information and guidance. The American College of Dentists provides a digital compilation of the 52 ethical dilemmas (PDF) published in the Texas Dental Journal from 1993 to 2005 and authored by the late Dr. Thomas K. Hasegawa and others. The scope and depth of ethical problems in the delivery of dental care will vary greatly. WARNING! Ethical dilemmas arise when one or more ethical principles or core values are in conflict. Please click CONTINUE below to return to your previous page to complete the process. Or should they educate the parents further and hope that conditions improve? This raises the dilemma as to whether the painkiller should be prescribed. Treat the children if and when they present for treatment would be acknowledging the autonomy of the parent to choose for her minor children. The Dental Hygiene Code of Ethics describes views on morals and ethics that should serve as a guide. You did not finish creating your certificate. Discuss the elements of autonomy, fidelity, and confidentiality as they are incorporated in the ethics of. This principle expresses the concept that professionals have a duty to be fair in their dealings with patients, colleagues and society. A child comes in with multiple oral issues that seem to stem from general neglect. The patient’s previous six to 12 months of treatment and most current x-rays could be discussed. In order to attract new patients as customers, a dentist may be tempted to create advertisements with exaggerated or false claims. Recognize common ethical dilemmas in dentistry. However, whether we realize it or not, many decisions that confront dental assistants are truly ethical dilemmas. Dental assistants will probably face some ethical dilemmas during their careers, and the ADAA upholds the highest code of conduct in any and all cases. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. The children are healthy, happy and well-adjusted --- Mom is involved, cooks and cares for them and is present in the dental office. In this hypothetical case, additional options might be available. #4 is the first option chosen in this situation because the children are in the dental office and all indications are that the Mom will proceed with treatment. However, they are not around enough to teach and enforce proper oral hygiene. Many examples of ethical dilemmas in dentistry may arise over deciding what is best for the patient when different courses of action conflict with each other. Since 2004, the Council on Ethics, Bylaws and Judicial Affairs has contributed a series of articles discussing ethical dilemmas confronted in the practice of dentistry. They may also be tempted to speak ill of another dental practice to poach patients. Dilemmas may also arise when it … Throughout the history of humanity, people always faced ethical dilemmas, and philosophers aimed and worked to find solutions to the problems. Language Barrier. Are dentists influenced by gifts and incentives, and should professional codes of conduct be updated to provide clearer guidelines for interactions with patients, colleagues and industry so as to avoid conflicts of interest in dentistry? Some Thoughts on the Dilemmas Faced by Dental Specialists. When tough decisions need to be made on behalf of our patients, we need the tools to do it. The interpreter tells you that you should inform child protective services (CPS) because of this high level of neglect. A patient may have just had oral surgery. The dentist has a duty to treat people fairly. Log in here. Should the practitioner inform child protective services and risk further hardship for the family? Summary of article “Pharmacies, Pharmacists, and Conscientious Objection” by Mark R. Wicclair and 4 questions. As professionals, dental hygienists often have choices to make in response to issues and dilemmas within their practice settings. She invites you to their church for a special festival -- a feast and a dance to celebrate the end of the harvest. Each situation involving human beings will be unique since each problem or dilemma will have distinguishing aspects. An example of a true ethical dilemma is when the principle of nonmaleficence is in conflict with the principle of autonomy in a specific situation. In the infection requiring hospitalization subset, all patients were hospitalized, and … Recent figures published by Dental Protection revealed that the willingness in the UK to sue dentists outstripped even the litigation-loving USA. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. That is a very difficult question to answer as the perception and awareness of ethical issues varies with the individuals involved. How do you respond? The model is diagramed in a circle as information can change requiring the clinician to reframe the initial question and begin again based on new facts. The following listing provides the general categories that have been acknowledged as ethical dilemmas in the dental ethics literature.8,10,11. Many of these choices are cut-and-dried and based upon a definitive need in providing a dental service to a patient. Explore positive examples of professionalism within dentistry. After your examination of the three children, you too are very concerned about the level of dental disease you have observed as they fit the definition of dental neglect in your state. Do you want to continue logged in? Address staff consistency and continuity. As professionals, we need be familiar with the code of ethics to help guide our behavior. The family was referred from a local church which has been helping a number of immigrant families in the community. Sign up now. Commonly, an opioid painkiller is prescribed to manage pain after the surgery. By far, the following approaches to solve an ethical dilemma were deduced: 1. Patients rights and medical ethics. The same freedom, however, brings moral, ethical, and business dilemmas that are new to most dentists early in their careers, having very little training in the business of dentistry. Government Dental College Department of Periodontics Abstract In modern dentistry, like other branches of medicine, a set of principles contribute in establishing codes of ethics. Your session is about to expire. No studies or evidence exists documenting the volume of problems. Should the dentist tell the patient to come back later when the pits have developed into cavities, or seal them and bill it to the insurance company as fillings? Often discussing a case like this among colleagues would result in additional thoughts, suggestions and options. As dentistry moved into the twenty-first century the attention to ethics would have to be even greater. Informing CPS would most likely not get dental care any faster for these children. A simple sealant would prevent these from becoming cavities. M.A. Discerning or being aware that an ethical issue is present is always the first step followed by defining the aspects of the problem. Dental Hygiene; Career Development; Ethics in dental hygiene. It explores real life ethical dilemmas dental students and new dentists may face and recommends activities that enhance the public trust of the profession. continuing the care that starts in your chair, Procter & Gamble - Crest + Oral-B Give Back, Over treatment and poor quality dental treatment, Deceptive dental marketing and advertisements, Challenges with capacity and informed consent, Conflict or unethical behavior among clinicians, Challenges arising from management, finance or legal issues. Refute the paradox (dilemma): The situation must be carefully analyzed. Dental practitioners face a range of potential conflicts of interest. Here are some examples and words of encouragement from the ADAA president. I need a summary of the article "Recognizing Conscience in Abortion Provision" by Lisa H. Harris, M.D., Ph.D. How can autonomy affect the ethical principles of health care workers? Explain how tort law, criminal law, and contract law directly impact health care professionals. That is a very difficult question to answer as the perception and awareness of ethical issues varies with the individuals involved. Summarize informed consent and implied consent with regard to patients, and analyze the difference between the two. In the end, it all boils down to the ability of the practitioner to discern right from wrong and act accordingly. However, the patient's insurance only covers fillings, not sealants. To accommodate these patients and facilitate treatment, the practice employs several interpreters and dental assistants from these various communities. Applying the Ethical Decision-making Model. In this post, I'm just going to focus on the issues those who already made the decision to specialize are facing and make some recommendations. In its broadest sense, this principle expresses the concept that the dental profession should actively seek allies throughout society on specific activities that will help improve access to care for all. Dilemmas may also arise when it comes to balancing the needs of the dentist's business with the needs of the patients. What is the responsibility of the clinician in this case to the children and the parent? For that reason, it was a surprise for me that Dental field was not the unique career which corresponds with my interest and personality type. Many examples of ethical dilemmas in dentistry may arise over deciding what is best for the patient when different courses of action conflict with each other. This situation is very familiar to dental hygienists. Even though Dental Hygiene was not in my top ten strong occupations, it fit in the first two of five top interest areas according to the Strong Interest Inventory. Failure to complete ALL the steps will result in a loss of this test score, and you will not receive credit for this course. As clinicians providing care and services, every dentist and dental hygienist will be faced with many choices, problems and dilemmas. Determine the history of the family and the length of time they have been in the US --- they are from a small country in Eastern Europe and have been in the US six months. The mother is pleasant and very caring for her children. In health care autonomy gives rise to the concept of permitting individuals to make decisions about their own health, which is the heart of many ethical dilemmas that occur in dentistry. Under this principle, the dentist's primary obligations include dealing with people justly and delivering dental care without prejudice. After elaborating on the scenario you could then tackle the question by applying the four pillars of Medical Ethics which applies to dentistry as well. Ethics in dentistry can be a very tricky and tough road to go down. Notably, the choice of one does not entirely solve the impending challenge. Both these situations result in cause for disagreement between the dental hygienist and his or her employer in which an ethical dilemma will ensue. Provide dental treatment to the children. This could potentially give rise to any number of conflicts. Wait until the children can been seen for treatment; monitoring their return visits to assure that dental care is provided in a timely manner. 10 Dental Negligence Case Examples. However, Boards of Dentistry often cite ethics as causative in cases considered by these agencies. Ethical Dilemma And Dental Hygienist. ... By choosing to become a dentist or dental hygienist, an individual assumes a responsibility to help others and professes to be a part of a profession. Begin education with the mother about dental disease and prevention. The children seem healthy, well-adjusted and pleasant but have obvious serious dental problems. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. They must balance the needs of being a clinician with the needs of running their operation and providing their employees with work. The latest figures state that there are 73 claims for every 1,000 dentists in the UK, compared with 58 in the US.